Your Complete Checklist for Finding the Best Roofing Contractor​

Drone-shot-roof-replacement-of-shingles-in-Cervin-Blvd-Austin-TX-78728-By-Legacy-roofing-Pros-3

When it comes to your roof, making the right decisions can feel like a lot of pressure—after all, it’s one of the most important parts of your home or commercial property. Whether you’re facing a minor repair or need a full replacement, finding a reliable roofing contractor can make all the difference in getting the job done right.

But let’s be honest: the process of hiring a contractor can be a bit overwhelming. There are so many options out there, and you want to be sure you’re choosing someone who will deliver quality work without giving you a headache. That’s where this checklist comes in.

We’ve put together this guide to help you navigate each step of hiring a roofing contractor. From assessing your roof’s condition to interviewing potential contractors, and everything in between, this list will make sure you’re well-prepared and confident in your decision. Think of it as your roadmap to a successful roofing project—one that leaves you with peace of mind and a roof you can trust for years to come.

 

1. Initial Assessment

Before diving into choosing a roofing contractor, it’s a good idea to start by taking a look at your roof. Is there a leak you’ve noticed? Missing shingles? Maybe a storm recently passed through? Getting a sense of what’s going on up there will help you figure out whether you’re dealing with a simple repair or something more serious, like a full replacement. If climbing up on the roof isn’t your thing, that’s okay—consider getting a professional inspection. This initial step is like taking your car in for a check-up; it helps you know what to expect.

Evaluate Roof Condition

Before you even start looking for a roofing contractor, take a good look at your roof. Is it leaking? Are there missing shingles? Has it been hit by a storm recently? Understanding the current state of your roof will help you determine whether you need minor repairs or a full replacement. If you’re not comfortable assessing the roof yourself, it might be wise to have a professional inspection done. This initial evaluation will give you a clear idea of what needs to be addressed.

Determine Project Scope

Knowing whether you need a complete roof replacement or just some repairs is vital. This will help you communicate your needs clearly to potential contractors and ensure you get accurate estimates. A well-defined project scope prevents misunderstandings and ensures that both you and the contractor are on the same page from the start.

2. Research and Preparation​

Now that you have an idea of what your roof needs, it’s time to do a little homework. You want to make sure the contractor you choose is actually local, properly insured, and has a good reputation. It’s like getting a referral before choosing a new doctor—you want someone who knows the area, has the right credentials, and comes highly recommended. Taking these steps now can save you from headaches down the road and make sure you’re working with someone trustworthy and experienced.

Local Contractor Verification

Ensure that the contractor you’re considering is genuinely local. With today’s technology, it’s easy for companies to appear local when they’re not. Check if they have a history of working in your area and have satisfied customers nearby. A local contractor is more likely to be familiar with local building codes and weather conditions, ensuring your roof is up to standard. Ask for proof of their local presence, such as business licenses or past projects in your community.

Insurance Verification

Always verify that the contractor carries valid insurance. Ask for a copy of their insurance certificate and ensure it’s not expired. This protects you from liability in case of accidents or damage during the roofing project. It’s also a sign of professionalism and reliability—reputable contractors will readily provide proof of insurance.

Check Reviews and Referrals

Look for numerous positive reviews online and ask the contractor for a list of past customers. Contact these customers to get their feedback. Genuine reviews from people in your area can give you a good idea of the contractor’s reliability and quality of work. Pay attention to both positive and negative reviews, and note how the contractor responds to any complaints.

3. Trust and Transparency​

Let’s be honest—hiring a roofer is a big deal, and you want to make sure you’re dealing with someone who’s upfront and honest. A good contractor should be like an open book when it comes to their process, timeline, and pricing. Clear communication is key here; it helps keep everyone on the same page and prevents any surprises along the way. Trusting your gut is important too—if something feels off, it’s okay to ask more questions or look elsewhere. A transparent relationship will make the whole experience smoother and less stressful.

Assess Transparency

A good contractor will be open and transparent about their process, timeline, and pricing. They should be willing to answer all your questions and provide detailed information about how they operate. Trust your intuition—if something feels off, it probably is. Transparency builds trust and ensures that you’re fully informed about every aspect of the project.

Communication Skills

Effective communication is key. The contractor should be responsive and clear in their communication. This ensures that you’re on the same page throughout the project and can avoid misunderstandings. Good communication also indicates that the contractor values your business and is committed to providing excellent service.

4. Professional Qualifications​

When it comes to roofing, you want to make sure the person you hire knows their stuff. Checking out their qualifications is a smart move. Things like training in Xactimate (especially if insurance is involved) and manufacturer certifications show that they’re up to date with industry standards and ready to do quality work. It’s kind of like choosing a mechanic who’s certified by the car manufacturer—you just feel better knowing they’ve got the right skills for the job.

Xactimate Training

If your roofing project involves an insurance claim, ensure the contractor is trained in Xactimate, a software widely used by insurance companies to assess damage and determine payouts. This training helps contractors work efficiently with insurance adjusters to get you the best coverage for your repairs. It also shows that the contractor is knowledgeable about the claims process.

Manufacturer Accreditation

Check if the contractor is accredited by the roofing material manufacturer you prefer. This accreditation ensures they are trained to install the materials correctly and may offer additional warranties. Manufacturer certifications often come with rigorous training and standards, ensuring that the contractor is skilled in using their products.

BBB Accreditation

Verify the contractor’s accreditation with the Better Business Bureau (BBB). The BBB provides ratings and reviews, helping you gauge the contractor’s reputation and reliability. Accreditation with the BBB is a sign of trustworthiness and adherence to ethical business practices.

Licensing and Associations

Understand the licensing requirements in your state. For example, in Texas, roofers don’t need a state license, but reputable contractors often belong to professional associations like the Roofing & Solar Reform Alliance (RSRA). Membership in such associations indicates a commitment to professionalism and ongoing training.

5. Insurance Considerations

Dealing with insurance can be tricky, but it’s important to know the ins and outs of your policy before getting started. Do you know your deductible? Does your policy cover the full replacement cost, or just the current value of your roof? These are the kinds of details that can make a big difference in what you’ll end up paying. Understanding your insurance coverage will help you avoid unexpected bills and make sure you’re fully prepared.

Understanding Your Insurance

Know your deductible and whether your policy offers Replacement Cost Value (RCV) or Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage. RCV pays for the full replacement cost minus your deductible, while ACV only covers the current value of your roof. Be aware of any policy exclusions that might affect your coverage. Understanding these details can help you avoid unexpected expenses and ensure you get the coverage you need.

6. Finding Potential Contractors

When it comes to finding the right contractor, personal recommendations can be golden. Asking friends, family, or even your insurance agent for suggestions is a great start. But don’t stop there—doing a quick online search and checking out reviews can also give you a sense of who’s out there. Just remember, not all reviews are created equal, so take the time to read them carefully. Putting in a little extra effort here can help you find someone who’s a perfect fit for your project.

Personal Recommendations

Ask friends, family, and trusted individuals for recommendations. Personal referrals can provide reliable insights into a contractor’s quality of work and professionalism. People you trust are likely to give you honest feedback about their experiences.

 

Insurance Agent Referrals

Consult your insurance agent for referrals. However, be aware that agents may have biases or receive incentives for referrals, so use their suggestions as a starting point for your own research. Insurance agents often work with multiple contractors and can provide insights into their reliability and workmanship.

Realtor Referrals

Realtors often have a list of trusted contractors they regularly work with. Their recommendations can be valuable, especially for large projects. Realtors rely on good contractors to maintain their reputation, so they’re likely to refer only the best.

Online Searches and Reviews

Use online searches to find contractors, but be cautious of paid ads and review directories. Focus on genuine reviews and check how contractors respond to negative feedback. This can give you a sense of their professionalism and customer service. Look for patterns in reviews—consistent positive feedback is a good sign of reliability.

Analyzing Online Reviews

Analyzing online reviews can be a bit tricky, but it’s an important part of finding the right roofing contractor. Here’s how to make sense of what you read:

  • Look for Patterns: When reading reviews, look for recurring themes. If multiple people mention the same issues or praises, it’s likely these are genuine aspects of the contractor’s service. For instance, if many reviewers comment on the contractor’s punctuality and professionalism, it’s a good sign that these are consistent strengths.
  • Consider the Volume of Reviews: While a high number of reviews can indicate a well-established contractor, don’t be swayed solely by numbers. A contractor with a few detailed and positive reviews may be just as reliable as one with hundreds. It’s the quality of the reviews that matters most.
  • Read Negative Reviews Carefully: Negative reviews can provide valuable insights into a contractor’s weaknesses. Pay attention to how the contractor responds to these reviews. A professional and courteous response can indicate their commitment to customer satisfaction. Look for resolution efforts—did the contractor address the issue and offer a solution?
  • Be Wary of Extremes: Extremely positive or negative reviews can sometimes be misleading. Look for balanced reviews that provide specific details about the experience. Reviews that are overly enthusiastic or scathing without much context can sometimes be fake or biased.
  • Check for Authenticity: Look for signs that the reviews are genuine. Authentic reviews often include specific details about the project, the contractor’s team, and the overall experience. Be cautious of reviews that are too generic or seem copied and pasted.
  • Use Multiple Sources: Don’t rely solely on one platform for reviews. Check multiple sites like Google, Yelp, BBB, and even social media pages. This will give you a broader perspective and help you spot any inconsistencies.

7. Interview Process

Think of the interview process as a chance to really get to know the contractor before you make a decision. It’s like a first date—you want to ask the right questions to see if you’re a good match. How do they handle unexpected issues? What’s their process like? Do they offer a warranty? These conversations will help you feel more confident in your choice and ensure that the contractor you hire is someone you can trust to do a great job.

Treat as a Job Interview

Meet potential contractors in person and treat the selection process like a job interview. Ask detailed questions about their services, experience, and how they handle unexpected issues. This will help you gauge their expertise and reliability. Prepare a list of questions and take notes during the interviews.

Prepare a list of questions to ask potential contractors, such as:

  • What is your process and timeline for the project?
  • How do you handle complaints or problems?
  • Can you provide examples of similar projects you’ve completed?
  • Do you offer a warranty on your work?
  • What safety measures do you take during the project?

8. Professionalism and Handling Complaints

No one’s perfect, and even the best contractors might run into a hiccup or two. What matters is how they handle it. A professional contractor will address any issues with respect and work to make things right. Checking out how they respond to complaints can give you a good idea of how they’ll treat you if something doesn’t go as planned. It’s all about finding someone who takes responsibility and values your satisfaction.

Evaluate Professionalism

Assess how the contractor handles negative reviews and complaints. A professional contractor will address issues courteously and work towards resolving them to the customer’s satisfaction. This can indicate their commitment to quality and customer service. Look for contractors who acknowledge mistakes and take steps to rectify them.

9. Final Steps Before Proceeding

Before you sign anything, take a close look at the contract. Make sure everything is clear, from the scope of work to the payment schedule to the warranty details. You don’t want any surprises later on, so it’s worth spending a little extra time now to review everything. And remember, a reasonable payment plan should have you making payments as the work is completed, not all upfront. Ensuring you’ve got all the details nailed down will help you feel confident that your project will go smoothly and finish up just the way you want it to.

Review Contract Details

Thoroughly review the contract before signing. Ensure all terms are clear, including the project scope, timeline, payment schedule, and warranty details. A detailed contract protects both you and the contractor and ensures that everyone understands their responsibilities.

Payment Terms

Understand the payment terms and schedule. Avoid contractors who demand full payment upfront. A reasonable payment plan usually involves an initial deposit followed by payments at specific milestones. This ensures that you only pay for work that has been completed satisfactorily.

Warranty and Guarantees

Confirm the details of any warranties and guarantees on the work and materials. A reputable contractor will stand by their work and provide a warranty for their services. Understand what is covered and for how long, and get all warranty information in writing.

Conclusion

Hiring a roofing contractor is a significant decision that requires careful consideration and preparation. By following this checklist, you can ensure you find a reliable and professional contractor who will provide quality work and peace of mind. Remember, your roof is a critical component of your property, and taking the time to hire the right contractor will protect your investment for years to come.

HAVE YOUR ROOF ASSESED

Contact Us Today!

Special Offer: Free Roof Inspection and Consultation!​

Are you unsure about the condition of your roof? Let Legacy Roofing Pros help! As the best roofing contractor for you, our team ensures top-quality work and exceptional customer service.

Don’t wait until it’s too late—schedule your free roof inspection now to protect your home or property with the trusted expertise of Legacy Roofing Pros.

We are offering a free roof inspection and consultation to help you determine the best roofing solutions for your needs. Our experts will thoroughly inspect your roof, provide a detailed assessment, and recommend the best options for repair, replacement, or upgrade.

Fill out the form below to schedule your FREE ROOF INSPECTION today!

FAQs: Hiring a Roofing Contractor

1. What Should I Look for When Hiring a Roofing Contractor?

When hiring a roofing contractor, look for key factors such as local presence, valid insurance, positive reviews, transparency, communication skills, and professional qualifications. Ensure the contractor is familiar with local building codes and weather conditions, has a history of satisfied customers, and is accredited by relevant manufacturers and associations.

At Legacy Roofing Pros, we meet all these criteria and more. Our team is local, insured, and highly reviewed. We prioritize clear communication and transparency throughout your project. Contact us today for a free roof inspection and experience our top-notch service.

2. Why Is It Important to Verify a Roofing Contractor’s Insurance?

Verifying a roofing contractor’s insurance is important to protect yourself from liability in case of accidents or damage during the project. It ensures that any injuries or property damage are covered, preventing unexpected expenses.

Legacy Roofing Pros carries comprehensive insurance to safeguard our clients and team. We provide proof of insurance readily, ensuring you can have peace of mind during your roofing project. Schedule your free inspection today and let us handle the rest.

3. How Can I Check a Roofing Contractor’s Reviews and References?

To check a roofing contractor’s reviews, look at multiple review platforms like Google, Facebook, and BBB. Pay attention to both positive and negative reviews, and note how the contractor responds to complaints. Contact references provided by the contractor to get firsthand feedback.

Legacy Roofing Pros boasts numerous positive reviews across various platforms. We encourage potential clients to read our reviews and contact our past customers. Our commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in our responses to feedback. Contact us for a free inspection and see why we’re highly recommended.

4. What Questions Should I Ask When Interviewing a Roofing Contractor?

When interviewing a roofing contractor, ask about their process, timeline, handling of complaints, examples of similar projects, warranties, and safety measures. Treat the interview as a job interview to gauge their professionalism and expertise.

At Legacy Roofing Pros, we welcome your questions and provide detailed answers. Our transparent process, safety protocols, and comprehensive warranties ensure your roofing project is in expert hands. Schedule your free roof inspection with us today.

5. How Can I Verify a Roofing Contractor’s Local Presence?

To verify a roofing contractor’s local presence, check their business licenses, past projects in the community, and ask for local customer references. Local contractors are more likely to be familiar with local building codes and weather conditions.

Legacy Roofing Pros is proudly local, with a strong presence and numerous satisfied customers in the area. We invite you to check our local projects and speak with our past clients. Contact us for a free inspection and work with a trusted local expert.

6. What Are the Benefits of Hiring a Manufacturer-Accredited Roofing Contractor?

Hiring a manufacturer-accredited roofing contractor ensures they are trained to install materials correctly and can offer additional warranties. Accreditation indicates a commitment to quality and adherence to industry standards.

Legacy Roofing Pros is accredited by leading manufacturers, ensuring we use the best materials and techniques. Our accreditation allows us to offer enhanced warranties, giving you extra protection and peace of mind. Schedule your free inspection to learn more about our quality services.

7. How Important Is Communication When Hiring a Roofing Contractor?

Effective communication is essential when hiring a roofing contractor. It ensures that you’re on the same page throughout the project, preventing misunderstandings and ensuring smooth progress. A responsive contractor values your business and is committed to excellent service.

At Legacy Roofing Pros, we prioritize clear and responsive communication. From initial consultation to project completion, we keep you informed every step of the way. Contact us today for a free inspection and experience our superior communication.

8. What Should I Know About My Insurance Before Hiring a Roofing Contractor?

Before hiring a roofing contractor, understand your insurance policy, including your deductible and whether you have Replacement Cost Value (RCV) or Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage. Be aware of any policy exclusions that might affect your coverage.

Legacy Roofing Pros can help you navigate the insurance process, ensuring you understand your coverage and get the most from your policy. We are trained in Xactimate to work efficiently with your insurance adjuster. Schedule a free roof inspection today for expert assistance.

9. How Do I Handle Negative Reviews When Considering a Roofing Contractor?

When considering negative reviews, look at how the contractor responds. A professional response to negative feedback can indicate their commitment to customer satisfaction. Look for patterns in the reviews and consider the overall context.

Legacy Roofing Pros takes customer feedback seriously and strives to address any concerns professionally. Our track record of resolving issues and maintaining high customer satisfaction speaks for itself. Contact us for a free inspection and see how we prioritize your satisfaction.

10. Why Is It Important to Have a Detailed Contract with a Roofing Contractor?

A detailed contract with a roofing contractor ensures that all terms are clear, including the project scope, timeline, payment schedule, and warranties. It protects both parties and prevents misunderstandings.

Legacy Roofing Pros provides comprehensive contracts that detail every aspect of your roofing project. Our transparent approach ensures you know exactly what to expect. Schedule your free roof inspection today and receive a clear, detailed contract for your peace of mind.

Related Articles:

Contact Us Today!

Get Your Free Roof Inspection Today!

Are you concerned about the condition of your roof? 

Fill out the form below to schedule your FREE ROOF INSPECTION today!

author avatar
James Tababa

Contact Us Today!

Get A Free Estimate