Choosing the Best Roof Upgrade: A Texas Homeowner's Guide


If you live in Texas, you know that your roof has to withstand a lot. From intense summer heat to powerful storms and occasional hail, your roof is your home’s first line of defense. So, when the time comes to replace it, you might be considering an upgrade. But is it worth it?

This comprehensive guide will help you navigate the different types of roofing upgrades available, their pros and cons, and whether an upgrade makes sense for your Texas home.

What Are Your Goals?

Before we dive into the specifics, let’s talk about why you might want to upgrade your roof. It’s essential to figure out what’s driving your decision. Is it because you’ve done some research and are genuinely interested in better roofing materials? Or is it because a salesman is convincing you it’s necessary?

Knowing your goal is key. Sometimes, roofing salespeople are more interested in upselling you than meeting your actual needs. They might appeal to your desire for a nicer-looking home or play on your fear of future damage. There’s nothing wrong with being presented with options, but it’s important to understand if these options align with your goals.

Standard asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in North America. They are composed of a fiberglass base mat coated with asphalt and topped with mineral granules.

These shingles are affordable, easy to install, and come in various colors. They typically last between 15 to 30 years.

Examples include basic 3-tab shingles that provide a flat, uniform look. These economy asphalt shingles are used in budget-conscious projects and are commonly found in many residential homes.
Here are the main roofing material upgrades from your standard shingle:
  1. Premium Standard Shingle
  2. High-Performance Shingle
  3. Impact Resistant Shingle
  4. Metal Roof
  5. Synthetic Composite Material

Pros and Cons of Different Roofing Materials

Let’s break down the types of roofing upgrades you might be considering to upgrade your standard shingle.

1. Premium Standard Shingle

A premium standard shingle is an upgraded version of the basic asphalt shingle, offering slight improvements in thickness and warranty.

These shingles are similar in composition to standard shingles but are a bit thicker and may come with a longer warranty, typically offering better performance in durability and lifespan.

  • Examples:
    • Laminated shingles that offer a more dimensional appearance.
    • Shingles with enhanced UV protection for longer life.
    • Thicker asphalt shingles that provide better wind resistance.


Advantages: This upgrade offers slightly thicker shingles with a marginally longer warranty. You might think that a thicker shingle means better durability and performance, and in some cases, that’s true. A longer warranty can provide peace of mind, knowing that you’re covered for a more extended period.

Disadvantages: The difference between a standard shingle and a premium standard shingle is often minimal. The increase in thickness and the extension of the warranty might not justify a significant price hike. Essentially, you’re paying more for a product that offers only a slight improvement in performance and longevity. If the cost difference is substantial, it’s usually not worth the investment.

When to Get an Upgrade: If the price difference is minimal and you are looking for a slight improvement in durability and warranty coverage, this might be a good option.

When to Skip the Upgrade: If the cost difference is significant and the benefits are marginal, you’re better off sticking with the standard shingle.

2. High-Performance Shingle

High-performance shingles are high-end asphalt shingles designed to provide superior aesthetics and performance.

These shingles are thicker, heavier, and have more intricate designs to mimic the appearance of materials like slate or wood shake. They offer enhanced durability and a distinctive look.

  • Examples:
    • Designer shingles that emulate the look of natural wood shakes.
    • Architectural shingles with multi-dimensional patterns for a rich appearance.
    • Shingles with high-definition color blends for an upscale look.

Advantages: Impact-resistant shingles are engineered to withstand severe weather conditions, particularly hailstorms. This can save you from frequent repairs and replacements due to storm damage, thus reducing the likelihood of filing insurance claims.

Some insurance companies offer significant discounts for homes with impact-resistant shingles, which can offset the initial cost of the upgrade. Moreover, these shingles can save you from paying deductibles in the event of a storm, as they are less likely to sustain damage.

Disadvantages: Not all insurance companies offer substantial discounts for impact-resistant shingles, so it’s crucial to check with your provider first. The cost of these shingles is higher than standard ones, and if your insurance company doesn’t offer a significant discount, the financial benefit might not justify the expense. Additionally, while these shingles are more durable, they’re not entirely immune to damage, so you might still face repairs in extreme conditions.

When to Get an Upgrade: If you live in an area prone to severe weather conditions, particularly hail, and your insurance company offers a significant discount for impact-resistant shingles, this upgrade is worth considering.

When to Skip the Upgrade: If severe weather is rare in your area or your insurance company does not offer substantial discounts, the higher cost might not be justified.

3. Impact Resistant Shingle

Impact-resistant shingles are designed to withstand severe weather conditions, particularly hail.

These shingles are made with reinforced materials to resist damage from hailstones and flying debris, often tested and rated for impact resistance.

  • Examples:
    • Shingles with a Class 4 impact resistance rating.
    • Reinforced asphalt shingles that can withstand hail and high winds.
    • Durable shingles designed to minimize storm damage and reduce insurance claims.

4. Metal Roof

A metal roof is a roofing system made from metal pieces or tiles characterized by its high resistance, impermeability, and longevity.

Metal roofs are lightweight, durable, and recyclable. They come in various styles, including standing seam, corrugated panels, and metal shingles.

  • Examples:
    • Standing seam metal roofs with raised seams for enhanced protection.
    • Metal panels with a ribbed design for added strength and aesthetic appeal.
    • Metal shingles that mimic the appearance of traditional roofing materials.

Advantages: Metal roofs are incredibly lightweight, which reduces the load on your home’s structure. This is particularly beneficial in areas with heavy snowfall, as metal roofs shed snow more efficiently than asphalt shingles.

They are also highly durable and can last significantly longer than traditional shingles. Metal roofs are recyclable, making them an environmentally friendly option. They are also resistant to fire, mildew, and pests, providing comprehensive protection for your home.

Disadvantages: Metal roofs are more expensive than standard shingles, and the initial investment can be quite high. Custom-made panels might result in a longer wait time for installation. Repairs can be more challenging and costly compared to asphalt shingles.

Additionally, securing insurance coverage for metal roofs can sometimes be difficult, as some insurance companies are hesitant to cover them due to their high replacement cost.

When to Get an Upgrade: If you live in an area with heavy snowfall, require a durable and long-lasting roof, and are looking for an environmentally friendly option, a metal roof is a good choice.

When to Skip the Upgrade: If the initial cost is prohibitive or if securing insurance coverage for a metal roof is problematic, you might want to consider other options.

5. Synthetic Composite Material

Synthetic composite roofing materials are engineered products designed to replicate the appearance of natural materials like slate, wood, or tile.

These materials are made from a blend of plastic, rubber, and other compounds, offering durability, lightweight, and ease of installation. They often use recycled materials and are recyclable themselves.

  • Examples:
    • Composite shingles that resemble natural slate but are lighter and more durable.
    • Synthetic tiles that mimic the look of clay or concrete tiles without the weight.
    • Composite shakes that provide the appearance of wood with added resistance to rot and insects.
Advantages: Synthetic composite materials offer a blend of the best features from other roofing types. They are lightweight, durable, and can mimic the look of high-end materials like slate or tile without the associated weight.

These materials are often made from recycled products and can be recycled themselves, making them an eco-friendly choice. They provide excellent durability, resisting impact, wear, and tear better than most other materials.

Disadvantages: The main drawback is cost. Synthetic composite materials are marketed primarily for luxury homes, and their price reflects that. They might not be practical for widespread use in a neighborhood of standard homes. While they offer significant benefits, the high cost can be a barrier for many homeowners.

When to Get an Upgrade: If you are looking for a high-end appearance without the weight issues of natural slate or tile, and if environmental sustainability is important to you, synthetic composite materials are a great option.

When to Skip the Upgrade: If you are on a budget or if your home is in a neighborhood where high-end roofing might not add significant value, this upgrade might not be necessary.


Making Your Decision

Whether or not to upgrade your roof comes down to your specific goals and circumstances. If you value a more luxurious look or need better protection from hail, an upgrade could be worth it. But it’s essential to balance the cost against the benefits.

To sum it up, upgrading your roof can offer many benefits, but it’s a decision that requires careful thought and planning. Make sure your choice aligns with your needs, and don’t be swayed by a sales pitch unless it genuinely meets your goals. By doing your homework, you can ensure that your investment in a new roof is truly worth it.

FAQs About Roof Upgrades in Texas

Upgrading your roof can provide numerous benefits, including improved durability, better weather resistance, enhanced aesthetic appeal, and increased property value. High-performance shingles, for instance, can withstand harsh weather conditions and last longer than standard options. Impact-resistant shingles can protect your home from hail damage, potentially lowering your insurance premiums.

At Legacy Roofing Pros, we offer a wide range of roofing materials, including high-performance and impact-resistant shingles. Our experts will help you choose the best options for your needs and ensure professional installation for maximum benefits.

Several signs indicate the need for a roof upgrade, such as frequent leaks, missing or damaged shingles, visible wear and tear, and high energy bills due to poor insulation. Additionally, if your roof is over 20 years old, it might be time to consider an upgrade.

We provide free, comprehensive roof inspections to assess the condition of your roof and recommend the best course of action. Our detailed inspection reports will help you understand whether a roof upgrade is necessary.

The best shingles for a roof upgrade depend on your specific needs and preferences. Premium standard shingles offer enhanced durability and aesthetics, high-performance shingles provide superior protection and a luxury look, and impact-resistant shingles are ideal for areas prone to severe weather.

Our team at Legacy Roofing Pros will guide you through the different types of shingles available and help you select the best option for your home. We use only high-quality materials to ensure long-lasting results.

Yes, metal roofs are an excellent option for roof upgrades in Texas. They are durable, lightweight, and resistant to fire, mildew, and pests. Metal roofs also reflect heat, which can help lower your cooling costs during the hot Texas summers.

Legacy Roofing Pros offers expert installation of metal roofs in various styles and colors. Our team will ensure that your new metal roof is installed correctly and efficiently, providing you with a reliable and energy-efficient roofing solution.

The duration of a roof upgrade depends on the size and complexity of your roof, the materials used, and the weather conditions. On average, a roof upgrade can take anywhere from a few days to a couple of weeks.

We strive to complete all roofing projects efficiently without compromising on quality. Our experienced team will provide you with a timeline for your roof upgrade and keep you informed throughout the process.

The cost of a roof upgrade varies based on factors such as the size of your roof, the materials chosen, and the complexity of the installation. Upgrading to high-performance or impact-resistant shingles may cost more initially but can save you money in the long run.

We offer competitive pricing and detailed quotes for all our roofing services. During your free consultation, we will provide a clear estimate of the costs involved in your roof upgrade and discuss financing options if needed.

Yes, a roof upgrade can significantly increase your home’s value. A new, high-quality roof not only enhances curb appeal but also improves the overall structural integrity of your home, making it more attractive to potential buyers.

Our professional roofing services ensure that your roof upgrade adds maximum value to your property. We use premium materials and provide expert installation to enhance both the aesthetic and functional aspects of your roof.

Spring and fall are generally the best times for a roof upgrade in Texas, as the weather is typically milder and more predictable. However, roof upgrades can be performed year-round with the right planning and precautions.

We work with you to schedule your roof upgrade at a convenient time, taking weather conditions into account to ensure a smooth installation process. Our team is equipped to handle roofing projects in various weather conditions.

Regular maintenance is key to extending the life of your roof after an upgrade. This includes periodic inspections, cleaning gutters, removing debris, and addressing minor repairs promptly to prevent larger issues.

We offer ongoing maintenance services to keep your roof in optimal condition. Our maintenance plans include regular inspections and timely repairs to ensure your upgraded roof remains in top shape for years to come.

Yes, Legacy Roofing Pros can assist you with the entire insurance claims process for roof upgrades. We work closely with your insurance company to ensure you receive the coverage you deserve and handle all the necessary paperwork and negotiations.

Our team has extensive experience with insurance claims and can guide you through each step, from the initial inspection to final approval. We aim to make the process as stress-free as possible, ensuring your roof upgrade is covered and completed efficiently.

Contact Us Today!

Get Your Free Roof Inspection Today!

Need reliable roofing services in Texas? Legacy Roofing Pros offers expert repairs, comprehensive maintenance, and additional home repair services. Our certified technicians provide quality roofing services. 

What our clients say

Client Testimonials

Michelle Broksas
Michelle Broksas
Read More
All my neighbors were having their roofs replaced due to hail and wind damage. Intending to sell my house, I thought the roof should be checked. Am I happy I did! My realtor suggested I contact a neighbor or two to inquire about their recent repairs. I then contacted Joshua Danna with Legacy Roofing Pros and he came right out. He identified hail damage, filed a claim with my insurance company and then met with the Inspector. We put a rush on it and a crew of 11 finished in half a day. The foreman, Luis, was such a pleasure to work with…always smiling and friendly. From beginning to end, I had a beautiful new roof in a week. Amazing! The owner of Legacy Roofing Pros, David Hanna, arrived to inspect the work and made sure everything was cleaned up properly and all loose nails removed from the grass and driveway. My experience with this company was 5+.

I would have given them a higher rating if I could.

Positively recommend this company and all those I mentioned above!
Donna Leighton
Donna Leighton
Read More
Positive: Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality, Responsiveness, Value

Sandra was amazing to work with! She went above and beyond, especially working with my insurance company. Since this was my first claim through insurance, she made it go much smoother for me. David thoroughly explained the processing of invoicing and payments. Most importantly, the crew performed a GREAT job on my roof including extensive repairs at no extra cost to me. I truly appreciate everyone who was a part of this job. Thank you again!!

Services: Roof repair for storm & wind damage, Roof inspection, Roof repair, Roof installation, Attic venting installation, Roof damage repair
Sarah Kitchen
Sarah Kitchen
Read More
Positive: Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality, Responsiveness, Value

After months of no-shows from other roofing companies, I called Legacy Roofing Pros and Dominique was SUPER helpful. He ALWAYS showed up, was always on time, professional, and friendly. He did an awesome job working with the insurance company to ensure a quick and easy project for me. It was seamless service! I would highly recommend them and Dominique to anyone!

Services: Roof inspection, Roof installation
Mark Murphy
Mark Murphy
Read More
If you're serious about your roofing contractor, read this!

I started at Legacy Roofing Pros about 6 months ago. I'm sad to say it's my last day but excited for what's next. Throughout this short 6-month period, I learned so much from Mr. Hanna(owner) that it literally inspired me to start my own roofing company.

I want to personally thank LRP and Mr. Hanna for the mentorship, guidance, and respect he showed and gave me.

These guys are straight shooters with top notch training and drive. Experts in their field with an amazing record.

Thank you, LRP
Tony Anthony
Tony Anthony
Read More
Replacing a roof is not something that we home owners do often so I was a little reluctant to start the process. But when I reached out to Legacy Roofing Pros and Dominique showed up at my house and explained the process it really put me at ease to start the process. He explained the steps in details about what will happen next in the process. Throughout the process he was just a text or phone call away if I had a question The day of the installation the crew arrived early and started removing the old roof. They placed tarp all around the yard to catch all debris and more importantly nails. I was very surprised when the job was done around midday. The crew was very professional and cleaned up everything. I am very happy with the job and a beautiful roof to look at for many years to come. My neighbor was impressed with their work and my feedback about the process and he also replaced his roof with Legacy Roofing Pros. Dominique and team, great job. Thank you all.
Rafael Rosado
Rafael Rosado
Read More
Very respectful and responsible. The workers are awesome, and they always attention to detail and explain everything very simply. The communication was exceptional, and always kept me informed on any changes. I'm very satisfied with my roof, windows, and gutters. I love my new roof and gutters.
David D
David D
Read More
Positive: Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality, Responsiveness

I am in the Dripping Springs area and needed someone to fix a roof that sprung a leak during our spring storm season. David and Legacy Roofing Pros came out and did a complete inspection for free. They worked with my insurance company on the claim and met the adjuster on his schedule, adjusting their schedule to make it work. After some back and forth with the insurance company I was able to get my roof repaired including some interior damaged that was caused during the last rainstorm. If you need someone in Dripping Springs or the surrounding areas don't hesitate to give them a call!

Services: Roof repair for storm & wind damage, Roof inspection, Roof installation, Roof damage repair
author avatar
James Tababa

Contact Us Today!

Get A Free Estimate